Dinner Menu

• Appetizers

  • Oysters On The Half Shell (6) 14.50

    we serve only large farm raised oysters from government inspected waters

  • Oysters Rockefeller (4) 14.00

    topped with spinach, parmesan and bacon

  • Stone Crabs

    (october 17 - may 15)

    A.Q. 

  • Shrimp 17.50

    colossal u-7 to u-10s with cocktail or remoulade sauce

  • Lobster Cocktail Remoulade

    A.Q. 

  • Baked Shrimp 18.50

    colossals with garlic butter, parmesan and bread crumbs

  • New York Prime's Classic Shellfish Bisque 12.00

  • Colossal Lump Crab Cocktail 18.50

    cocktail or remoulade sauce

  • Carpaccio 17.00

    prime beef tenderloin

  • Seafood Platters

    a selection of our appetizers for 4 or more people

    A.Q. 

  • Thick Cut Sizzling Bacon 12.00

    two thick slices served with Brooklyn French

• Usda Prime Steaks

  All Steaks are Usda Prime, including Filets, are Aged 28 Days and Prepared "Pittsburgh-style" with a Charred Exterior

  • Petite New York Strip - 10 Oz. 49.00

  • New York Strip - 16 Oz. 59.00

  • Bone-in Rib Steak - 22 Oz. 69.00

  • Center Cut Filet Of Rib Eye - 8 Oz. 42.00

  • Center Cut Filet - 12 Oz. Barrel Cut 72.00

  • Petite Filet - 8 Oz. Barrel Cut 54.00

  • Porterhouse For Two - 40 Oz. 99.00

  • Chopped Steak Of Prime, Aged Beef 29.50

  • Triple Cut Lamb Chops - Two 12 Oz. 49.50

  • Double Rib Veal Chop - 16 Oz. 49.00

  • Garlic Chicken 23.50

  • Salmon Topped With Sauteed Portobello Mushrooms 31.00

  • Redfish Amandine With Crabmeat 36.00

  • Sea Bass

    A.Q. 

  • Live Lobster - 3 to 13 Lbs.

    A.Q. 

• Salads

  Slightly smaller sizes available

  • Beefsteak Tomatoes And Onions 13.00

    served with "brooklyn french" dressing

  • Hearts Of Lettuce With Sliced Tomato 13.00

  • New York Prime's Chopped Italian Salad 13.00

    onions, tomatoes, red, yellow and green peppers, hearts of palm, anchovies, almonds, olive oil and bleu cheese

  • Caesar 13.00

• Sides

  Available In Individual Or Table Sized

  • Creamed, Steamed Or Garlic Spinach 13.00

  • Sauteed Mushrooms 13.00

  • Sauteed Onions 13.00

  • Asparagus With Hollandaise 13.00

  • Southwest Creamed Corn 13.00

    (Table size only)

  • Brussels Sprouts 13.00

  • Onion Straws 13.00

  • Onion Rings 13.00

  • Steak Cut French Fries 13.00

  • 1/2 Onion Rings And 1/2 Fries 13.00

  • Hash Browns 13.00

  • Lyonnaise 13.00

    hash browns with onions

  • Cheese Mashed Potatoes 13.00

    (Table size only)

  • Giant Baked Potato - 1 Pound Loaded 7.50

    fresh bacon, chives, sour cream and butter

  • Fettuccine Alfredo "The Recipe" 13.50